Let the autopsies begin, but don’t blame Trump alone when the Republican Congress has done virtually nothing since passing the Big Beautiful Bill. Read my new column from Real Clear Politics.
By FRANK MIELE
Just as one hopes that the Republican Party will do an autopsy of what went wrong on Election Day, Nov. 3, 2026, I have decided to do an autopsy of my own longstanding support of Donald Trump in order to determine if I need to make a course correction.
After all, the results of the midterms should encourage all conservatives to examine their own beliefs and to question whether the election results are a repudiation of those beliefs.
I don’t think I give away the plot when I say at the outset that the answer to my question is a firm no. Trump’s agenda, and his fierce determination to restore common sense to government, is not the problem. What went wrong was lackluster performance by Republican politicians in carrying out that agenda.
I am reminded of a column I used as the epilogue in my 2018 book “Why We Needed Trump: Part 3.” That column was written following the midterms during Trump’s first term and was titled “GOP looks to cut own throat with autopsy knife.” One of my conclusions was that Republicans lost power because they “sabotaged President Trump at every opportunity.”
Could the same be said for the leadership of John Thune as Senate majority leader? Yes. Believe it or not, House leadership has said that over 600 House-passed bills are pending action or awaiting votes in the Senate.
Do we have Thune to blame for the failure to pass popular legislation such as the election reforms in the SAVE Act? Yes indeed. And the less well-known Ratepayer Protection Act, which would have held large-load utility customers responsible for costs associated with their projects, passed the House on a 417-3 vote, but couldn’t reach the floor in the Senate due to a filibuster.
Which brings up another point: If Thune was unable to advance legislation because of the Senate’s filibuster rules, shouldn’t he have encouraged a vote to change those rules? After all, what should take precedence? A procedural rule, or the legislative commitments that Republicans made to voters? According to Thune, it was the unholy rule, the darn filibuster. We shall see whether Democrats feel so attached to tradition in the next session.
I know: In general, we conservatives should honor tradition, but that does not mean we should be tied to it. One of the reasons I have supported Donald Trump for years is because he represents a rare combination of respect for the past and a willingness to break with the present in order to achieve a better future.
I also know that he has a boundless capacity for optimism that often leads him to exaggerate his own successes and minimize his failures. That makes him easy to ridicule, and Democrats have certainly done their share of that.
But bottom line: Trump knew something was wrong with the country, and even more so with the Republican Party, and he vowed to fix it. That’s what I and millions of other voters responded to.
In a column in April 2015, two months before Donald Trump came down the golden escalator, I wrote:
“I’m thinking that if Republicans don’t care enough to defend their principles, then I don’t care enough to vote for them for president or any other office.”
That was an expression of frustration with decades of Republican leadership that never seemed to achieve anything.
It turned out that millions of other voters agreed with me, and Trump soared past a crowded field of Republican contenders in the 2016 primaries by promising to be different. Case in point? Border control. For years, we had talked about an illegal immigration problem, but nothing ever got done. Trump said he wanted to stop the insanity of open borders, and more than anything, that’s why he was elected. Then, when he got into office, he was blocked at every juncture by not just Democrats and activist judges but also Republicans in Congress.
If you want to know what went wrong for Republicans on Nov. 3, look no further. The same premise applies. Republicans in Congress just didn’t deliver – on their agenda, on their principles, on their promises.
That’s not true of Trump. Whatever you think of him, he has followed the formula I described in an August 2015 column when I praised his willingness to “challenge his fellow candidates to be political leaders instead of poll readers.”
Unfortunately, the Republicans in Congress didn’t respond to that challenge then (or now) with anything like the urgency or determination that was needed. It seemed as though every act they undertook, or every failure to act, hinged on how it might affect their election chances.
Does that mean the Republican Congress is totally to blame for the wipeout on Election Day? Well, let’s give some credit to the other side. The Democrats deserve recognition for having a salient message, and for their ability to convince the public that they will follow through.
Trump knows that he too is partly responsible. Even though border control is the greatest accomplishment of his second term, he himself admits that excesses in immigration enforcement cost the party votes.
But perhaps the most important factor in the election was the war in Iran. If any one thing can explain Trump’s decline in popularity, it was his decision to lead in the fight to make sure that the Islamic Republic never achieves its goal of becoming a nuclear power.
Although it was costly in dollars, the mission was a strategic success, with few American casualties. But both the president and the Republicans in Congress share the blame for not explaining the war better and justifying its effects on fuel prices.
Unfortunately, the American public has a short memory. Just as they forgot how bad the border was before Trump was inaugurated the second time, they also put out of mind the threat of a nuclear Iran. All they know is that gasoline prices went up a couple of dollars per gallon.
Donald Trump had to know that another war in the Mideast would damage him and the Republican Party politically, but he did it anyway – because somebody had to do it.
The moral of the story is do what’s right, and don’t expect to be rewarded for it just because it’s right. Or as I said 11 years ago, be a leader, not a poll reader.
The Democrats get their turn in the barrel next. Let’s see what the public thinks of them in two years.
About Heartland Diary USA
Heartland Diary is solely operated by Frank Miele, the retired editor of the Daily Inter Lake in Kalispell, Montana. If you enjoy reading these daily essays, I hope you will SUBSCRIBE to www.HeartlandDiaryUSA.com by leaving your email address on the home page. Also please consider purchasing one of my books. They are available through the following Amazon links. My new book is “What Matters Most: God, Country, Family and Friends” and is a collection of personal essays that transcend politics. My earlier books include “How We Got Here: The Left’s Assault on the Constitution,” “The Media Matrix: What if everything you know is fake?” and the “Why We Needed Trump” trilogy. Part 1 is subtitled “Bush’s Global Failure: Half Right.” Part 2 is “Obama’s Fundamental Transformation: Far Left.” Part 3 is “Trump’s American Vision: Just Right.” As an Amazon Associate, I may earn referral fees for qualifying purchases through links on my website.
(If you are exhausted from the dirty ads and the empty rhetoric, I’ve got bad…
When Trump came to Kalispell, Montana, I got to see firsthand just how good a…
Democrats will pretend to be anything to win your votes. This time around they are…
(If I was starting to doubt Trump, RFK Jr. snapped me out of it. Read…
(President Trump says he wants to beat Dems in the midterms, but why might he…
Just like sometimes you have to do an intervention to help an alcoholic face reality,…